• Banner 1
  • Banner 2
  • Banner 3

Welcome to Jonathan’s Restaurant

Jonathan’s Restaurant, nestled in Garden City Park, NY, offers a delightful blend of Mediterranean and American cuisine. With a focus on quality and service, this restaurant stands out for its elegant ambiance and attentive staff. Diners rave about the exceptional dishes, from the flavorful veal parm to the decadent chocolate ganache cake. The management's dedication to creating unforgettable experiences is evident, making it a go-to spot for special occasions or a memorable dinner. Whether you're craving the best chicken Marsala or exploring their extensive menu, Jonathan’s Restaurant promises an exceptional dining experience.

Jonathan’s Restaurant: Reviews & Ratings

AJ L.
AJ L.

Came here for dinner and had a pleasant experience. I was with a large group and we all ordered appetizers, entrees and a dessert. I ordered the veal parm which was good, although they forgot my pasta so I had to remind them about that, but otherwise it was tasty and crisp. The sauce is a bit on the sweater side. For dessert I got the chocolate ganache cake which was a HUGE portion, but I think the cake was a bit dry. Service was ok. Food came out quickly but after we were server, we weren't really checked up on and the place wasn't that busy either. Overall, it was a positive experience. The restaurant itself is quite lovely. Would come back.

Colleen K.
Colleen K.

We just got home from my son's Christening and I needed to write a review immediately. We hosted our son's Christening at Jonathan's and it was an absolutely delightful experience from start to finish. We have to start with the staff...It was a pleasure to work with the managers, Frank and Peter, while planning the event. We have to shout out the staff who answered the phones every time I called with silly questions or requests messing up to the event. The servers, Miguel and Billy, assigned to our party were outstanding! They kept the drinks coming and managed the food perfectly throughout the event. Elvin, the bartender, was also amazing and friendly! From the moment we arrived, we were greeted with genuine hospitality and professionalism. The staff went above and beyond to accommodate our needs, ensuring every detail was taken care of flawlessly. There was another event across from us at the same time, but it did not interfere with our event at all. They seamlessly handled our guests, offering impeccable service throughout the event. Now for the ambiance...The restaurant's charming ambiance provided the perfect environment for our celebration, blending elegance with warmth effortlessly. About the food - it was simply outstanding! Every dish was expertly prepared, showcasing fresh, high-quality ingredients. We chose the "Complete Menu" option and it was worth the money! The management team deserves special recognition for their attentiveness and flexibility in accommodating our specific requests. They worked closely with us in the planning stages, providing valuable insights and making sure everything ran smoothly on the day of the event. In summary, our experience at Jonathan's was nothing short of exceptional. It's clear that they excel in creating memorable moments for their guests. Whether you're planning a special occasion like ours or simply seeking a memorable dinner, definitely give it a try!

Apryl H.
Apryl H.

My best friend and I went to Jonathan's for Restaurant Week. The food was amazing. We enjoyed it so much. It was hands down the best chicken Marsala I've ever tasted. The service was great. I loved the ambiance of the restaurant. The spacing of the tables were great and you felt like you had privacy. I will definitely go back to dine again.

Juju W.
Juju W.

We booked a private event here for 25 guests and the food was delish. Service was great however a minor thing was since we had a long banquet seating, the waiters reached over guest's heads to serve the people on the other side of table. They did have a clear space on the other side but that took more walking and effort to reach. Otherwise service was great. Our custom cake came out beautifully and was so delish w dulce de leche filling. Entrees were also delicious and everyone was happy. Glad We picked this place for our holiday party.

Jill M.
Jill M.

Enjoyed our first experience at Jonathan's very much. The bread basket had a nice selection of different breads. The regular menu is extensive but choose mostly from the special menu. My duck tacos and lamb shank were superb. My husband enjoyed his grilled seafood appetizer and the shrimp and crab risotto special. Very nice selection of cocktails. The icing on the cake was our server Billy. Very personable young man who was extremely accommodating. 5 stars just for him!!

Location

Welcome to Jonathan’s Restaurant, a Mediterranean-American culinary gem located at 3000 Jericho Turnpike in Garden City Park, NY. This restaurant not only offers a wide range of delectable dishes but also provides top-notch services such as reservations, delivery, takeout, catering, and free Wi-Fi.

Customers have raved about the exceptional experience they had at Jonathan’s Restaurant. AJ L. mentioned the tasty veal parm and chocolate ganache cake, while Colleen K. expressed her delight with the staff's professionalism during her son's Christening event. Apryl H. praised the amazing food, particularly the chicken Marsala, and Juju W. commended the delicious custom cake served at her private event. Jill M. highlighted the extensive menu options and exceptional service from their server, Billy, giving the restaurant 5 stars.

From the pleasant ambiance to the mouthwatering dishes, Jonathan’s Restaurant truly stands out as a must-visit destination for food enthusiasts. The blend of Mediterranean and American flavors, along with the impeccable service, creates a memorable dining experience for every guest. Whether you're craving a hearty Mediterranean dish or a classic American favorite, Jonathan's Restaurant has something to satisfy every palate.